Home Insurance — Ithaca, NY
Homeowner's insurance is required by every mortgage lender, but the right policy does more than check a box. These local insurance agents serve Tompkins County homeowners with coverage tailored to the Ithaca area's specific risks.
Home Insurance near Ithaca (9)
Updated April 8, 2026
The most reviewed on Google is State Farm – Nick Romo (426 reviews, 4.8 rating). 1 provider in this list is verified by Cornerpin Real Estate.
-
AllstateBrad Scott
-
Bailey Place InsuranceVal VanGorder
-
Liberty MutualEvan Schapiro
-
Maguire Family Insurance CompanySuzanne Organ
-
Security Mutual Insurance
-
State Farm – Nick RomoNick Romo
-
State Farm – Zach Clark VerifiedZach Clark
-
Tompkins InsuranceMatthew Edmister
-
True InsuranceJolene Brooker
Verified service providers have confirmed their details directly with Cornerpin. We regularly contact every provider in this directory to keep the list accurate and current.
What to Look For in Home Insurance
Get quotes from at least three agents and compare not just premiums but deductibles, exclusions, and coverage limits. Ask about flood and sewer backup riders — standard policies typically exclude both, and Ithaca's terrain makes water damage a real concern. Bundle with auto for discounts, but verify the bundled rate actually beats standalone policies.
