Mortgage Lenders — Ithaca, NY

Name: CORNERPIN
Price range: $$$

Whether you're a first-time buyer or refinancing, choosing the right lender affects your rate, closing costs, and experience. These local mortgage professionals serve the Ithaca and Tompkins County market.

Mortgage Lenders near Ithaca (10)

Updated April 2, 2026

The most reviewed on Google is Beginnings Credit Union (58 reviews, 2.4 rating). 5 providers in this list are verified by Cornerpin Real Estate.

1st Priority Mortgage

4.4 (29)

Jennifer Rich

607-342-1973 www.jrich.1stprioritymortgage.com
Alternatives Federal Credit Union

4.3 (12)

Phil Shay

607-216-3474 alternatives.org
Beginnings Credit Union Verified

2.4 (58)

Kim Rozell

607-229-5008 beginnings.com/personal/home-loans/meet-the-mortgage-team/kimberly-rozell
Crosscountry Mortgage / Majzner Group

Kathleen McEldowney

718-314-0669 www.crosscountrymortgage.com
M&T Bank Verified

5.0 (1)

Ryan Wuerthner

607-237-8884 locations.mtb.com/ny/ithaca/bank-branches-and-atms-ithaca-ny-461.html
M&T Mortgage Corp.

Boynton, Jessica

607-351-5289 mtb.com
Movement Mortgage Verified

4.9 (48)

Kathleen Bange

607-731-5874 www.lo.movement.com/kathleen-bange/home
Premium Mortgage Corporation Verified

Scott Sullivan

585 944 3709 premiummortgage.com
Prime Lending

5.0

Michael Davis

585-329-1183
Tioga State Bank Verified

Erin Hudak

607-354-6255 tiogabank.com

Verified service providers have confirmed their details directly with Cornerpin. We regularly contact every provider in this directory to keep the list accurate and current.

What to Look For in Mortgage Lenders

Compare APR (not just interest rate) across at least three lenders. Ask about their average closing timeline — in the competitive Ithaca market, speed matters. Local lenders often have more flexibility with unique properties like those on leased land or with non-standard construction.