Propane Dealers — Ithaca, NY

Name: CORNERPIN
Price range: $$$

Propane powers heating, cooking, and backup generators in many Tompkins County homes, particularly in rural areas outside the natural gas service area. These local suppliers handle delivery and tank service.

Propane Dealers near Ithaca (7)

Updated April 8, 2026

The most reviewed on Google is Ehrhart Energy (290 reviews, 4.4 rating). 1 provider in this list is verified by Cornerpin Real Estate.

E&V Energy

4.2 (113)

607-241-1010 eandvenergy.com/service-areas/newfield-ny

Heating Oil Dealers HVAC Propane Dealers
Ehrhart Energy Verified

4.4 (290)

607-387-8881 ehrhartenergy.com

Heating Oil Dealers Propane Dealers
FerrellGas

2.9 (49)

607-869-2341 ferrellgas.com/propane-locations/ny/ovid/water-street/214560
JB Smith Heating

3.8 (13)

Scott Smith

607-753-1004 jbsmithheating.com/about-us
Mirabito Energy Products

3.3

607-272-2250 mirabito.com

Heating Oil Dealers HVAC Propane Dealers
Suburban Propane

3.5 (60)

607-753-8248 suburbanpropane.com

Heating Oil Dealers Propane Dealers
Sweetwater Propane

5.0 (7)

717-740-3430 sweetwaterpropane.com/our-locations/geneva-ny

Verified service providers have confirmed their details directly with Cornerpin. We regularly contact every provider in this directory to keep the list accurate and current.

What to Look For in Propane Dealers

Compare per-gallon pricing, but also ask about tank rental fees, delivery minimums, and hazmat charges. Some companies offer price-lock or cap programs to protect against winter price spikes. Ask whether they own the tank or if you can — owning your tank lets you switch suppliers freely.